Showing posts with label Fin 48. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fin 48. Show all posts

Monday, May 12, 2008

Mexico's Dictamen Fiscal Is Similar to New Fin 48 in the US

Excerpt from Practical Mexican Tax Strategies
Published by WorldTrade Executive, Inc.

By Steve Axler & Dinorah Gonzalez
(Halliburton)

One of the concerns resulting from the introduction of FIN 48 for many in-house tax practitioners, especially for US based multinational companies, is that the US Internal Revenue Service would now essentially have a road map to various tax positions taken by the taxpayer. However, the disclosure of tax positions to the tax authorities is not a new or unusual event in Mexico. In fact, for large taxpayers in Mexico this is an annual occurrence. known in Spanish as the Dictamen Fiscal.

Often simply referred to just as “the Dictamen”, this a tax audit of a Mexican legal entity or person that carries out business activities or any foreign residents with a permanent establishment in Mexico. The Dictamen Fiscal can only be performed by a registered and certified Mexican public accountant. Upon completion of the Dictamen, the accountant will issue a report which will be filed with the Mexican tax authorities (Servicio Administración Tributaria or “SAT”) stating whether, according to the applicable tax regulations and audit standards, the taxpayer has complied with its obligations. The public accountant is required to sign the Dictamen under penalty of perjury.

It cannot be emphasized enough the influence that a Mexican statutory auditor has regarding the tax positions taken by a taxpayer in Mexico. A trap for a new or unsophisticated investor in Mexico is to execute a reorganization or to take an uncertain tax position without first discussing this with the auditor. In the best circumstances, if the taxpayer has not discussed the transaction with the auditor before the Dictamen review begins, much time, effort, expense and stress will be incurred in getting the auditor comfortable with the transaction given the limited time frame the auditor has to understand the transaction and complete the Dictamen.

In the very worst scenario, the auditor may not agree with a position taken by the taxpayer and may not be willing to sign the Dictamen or will give a negative opinion. The taxpayer is then faced with the decision to unwind the transaction, find another auditor, or in the worst situation face a tax audit from the SAT. Consequently, the taxpayer will be in the difficult position to explain why there is a negative opinion or no Dictamen at all.

To learn more about the Dictamen Fiscal in Practical Mexican Tax Strategies

To sign up for your free Latin American Law & Finance Executive Briefing


Thursday, January 24, 2008

Fin 48 and Tax Risk in Latin America

In a recent discussion, PricewaterhouseCoopers' John Salerno joined the editors of WorldTrade Executive's Practical Latin American Tax Strategies to talk with ADM's Robert Frable and Sony's Marc Lewis about their tax operations in Latin America, their new procedures for dealing with FIN 48, and transfer pricing procedures. This excerpt from that interview takes a look at their strategies surrounding FIN 48:

Strategies: What has your overall experience been in managing the implementation of FIN 48 in the region?

Lewis: It is hard to say that the Latin American region presents something that is unique within FIN 48 implementation versus some of the other regions but I think one thing to consider is how much reliance a taxpayer can place on the availability of Competent Authority or APA relief. To a certain extent, it is dependent upon how active the Competent Authority is between different countries and how active the APA programs are between different countries. Latin America, Mexico and probably some others have pretty robust activities. However, in other countries, it is just building up, so I do not think you are at the same level as you see in some of the countries in Europe, Japan and other places where you can rely upon a Competent Authority or APAs in the assessment of uncertain tax positions.

Frable: FIN 48 was an interesting experience with this being the implementation year. I think everybody was surprised at how much time they ended up spending on the implementation. It took away from your day-today responsibilities. I think it is going to get better; tax departments, controllers and even outside auditors had to work through a learning curve.

More